David Miliband

Foreign Secretary

FCO Logo
Sunday 23 March, 2008

The things they tell you...

We all know that Finland is properly renowned for being top of the best leagues - not football but education. The PISA education studies say Finland's 15 year olds have the highest educational achievement, and there is also the least inequality of achievement of OECD countries in Finland But on a trip last week I was also told in my FCO brief that Finland is top of the mosquito swatting championships...surely not...who counts these things?

Finland, Denmark and Sweden, which I visited this week, are all countries which have made a virtue of their openness, and have committed money and people to furtherance of decent values around the world.  Two Danish soldiers were killed in Afghanistan last week - further testimony to that country's commitments. 

But the Finns and Swedes are not in NATO - hence the importance of the EU/NATO coordination that I discussed in all three countries. The membership of the two organisations has significant overlap, but they were founded to do different things, and should be complementary in their activities.  They can only do this if there is proper coordination - in Brussels and on the ground in Kosovo and Afghanistan. One important by-product of the talks this week on Cyprus will I hope be the confidence on both sides to try to overcome the barriers to NATO/EU cooperation.

Democracy Canon

I spoke to 400 students at Copenhagen University about the future of Europe. A week before the Danish government published their 'Democracy Canon' - "intended to act as an inspiration for a debate on the understanding of the prerequisites for democracy in Denmark."

The canon lists 35 key events, philosophical trends and political texts that have had the most significance for Danish democracy.  The Magna Carta and John Locke get a mention alongside The Jutland Act and the Danish Farm and High School Movement as well as the Salman Rushdie affair and...notably for a country often alleged to be viscerally Euro-sceptic... the EU Treaties.  Before this sets off a great debate..."EU Referenda" get a mention too.

It's a nice idea.  A British list would probably be shorter (Magna Carta, Reform Acts...) and more focused on our own history (can't see Tocqueville making it, or Greek democracy).  Maybe that is why our notion of democracy is a bit thin.

Five Years On

The media and public have rightly paused this week to reflect on the Iraq War five years on.  I think the essential point is that the war itself went better than people feared, but building the peace has been much more difficult than people expected.  For many people the judgment of history has already been made.  But the next five years, not the last five, will be decisive for political reconciliation, for security improvement, and for economic reconstruction.  The BBC/ABC poll this week makes striking reading.  It is not that things are sorted; it is that the undoubted steps backwards in 2004/5 have been reversed; and that confidence creates its own momentum.

We will debate the timing of an inquiry into the origins of the war in the House of Commons on Tuesday.  The important work now underway across the country, including in Basra where over 4,000 British troops are doing important work in support of the Iraqi Security Forces, means that the government do not believe the time is now right for such an inquiry.  Let's stay focused on the job in hand.

  • Share this with:
Comments:

David, Denmark is a particularly poor example to quote when discussing European referenda considering that when the Danish people were unhappy with the treaty of Maastricht and voted against it they had a second referendum later to get it through When the result of the referendum was announced, the outcome and frustrations about the referendum being held only a year after the Danes had rejected the previous treaty led to riots in the Nørrebro area of Copenhagen, during which the police fired 113 shots into a crowd when it was trapped. 11 people were subsequently treated for gunshot wounds. This does not smack of democracy in action as much as political powers getting their own way by using a particularly blunt instrument. I suspect that something similar will happen in Eire when they get their promised referendum on the treaty of Lisbon. The result will be ignored until the people come to their senses and vote the way the government wants them to. brI believe that Shakespeare had the correct phrase for it "Hamlet." Act I, Scene 4 when Marcellus said "Something is rotten in the state of Denmark".

Posted by Paul Everest on March 23, 2008 at 09:51 PM GMT #

"Maybe that is why our notion of democracy is a bit thin."brbrIf you were referring to the Labour government, most people would agree wholeheartedly, however, you appear to be referring to the British people you know, those people you are supposed to represent not have utter disdain for, in which case your remark is both fatuous and offensive. I believe an elaboration or apology is called for. brbrCongratulations though on being able to google "democracy" and come up with Tocqueville.br

Posted by Paul Buddery on March 24, 2008 at 05:01 AM GMT #

It perplexes me that so many people seem certain that the Iraq War and Britain's involvement in it were "Bad Things". Equally troubling is that some people seem 100 convinced that the reverse is true. Perhaps our modern media is to blame - it doesn't tolerate doubt especially if it's expressed by a politician.brbrFor what it's worth I believe the war was a mistake but, perversely perhaps, that, once it became inevitable, Britain was right to join. But neither opinion is more certain than about 60:40. It’s a shame we won’t be here to see what historians make of it in a century or so.brbrYou're spot on that the future is more important than the past. Having lived all my adult life fearing that the Northern Ireland situation would never be resolved, I’m now optimistic that stability can one day be restored to places currently suffering under seemingly intractable problems...brbrThe baton is passing from my generation to yours. Do your best!

Posted by Brian Hughes on March 24, 2008 at 11:19 AM GMT #

Post a Comment:
  • HTML Syntax: NOT allowed