David Miliband

Foreign Secretary

FCO Logo
Friday 05 December, 2008

Islam of the West not in the West

Questions of identity are always difficult. Last week in Islamabad I was privileged to sit on a panel with four successful young British professionals of Pakistani origin, in front of several hundred students from the International Islamic University.
 
The audience asked a series of searing questions about being Muslim in Britain, and about British attitudes to Islam. My co-panellists were equally searing in their answers. They said they were comfortable in their multiple identities - as British nationals, as Muslims, as women, as doctors, as television producers. They talked honestly about the issues facing the British-Pakistani community. They demanded that Muslims lead by example, and have a duty to demonstrate what it means to be both Muslim, and to be a British Muslim.
 
The discussion was not an easy one. We covered hard questions about what causes terrorism, and about perceptions of the West among Muslims. But the event gave me real hope. The four young British Muslims on the panel were deeply impressive, and offered a clear and compelling vision of what the future might be for Muslims in the UK. And the audience was willing to debate all these questions, and listen, even where many did not agree.
 
Its a discussion I'd like to continue. Have a look at the video of the session. Are there other questions you would like me and the panel to answer?

 

  • Share this with:
Comments:

The whole point of being British is that we do not posess one unique national identity and we respect that fact. We are a patchwork of uniquely different people, each with different multiple identities. This, somewhat ironically, is what creates the collective identity of "British". We have different identities, yet we respect the right of each of us to possess those different identities. We also share these multiple identities within society, thereby marking us out as one of the most tolerant nations in history. Remember, there is nothing more British than going for a curry.

Posted by Justin on December 06, 2008 at 07:37 PM GMT #

In my question, I'd like to touch the causes of terrorism. According to the american philosopher and sociologist Francis Fukuyama 'islamic-terrorists, specially those who perpetrated the London bombings and the september 11 were predominantly european residents and were deeply influenced by a western culture, but at the same time pointing out to the fact that's almost impossible to turn people against their own people... Would you concur with the brodely established opinion that extremist moods have no nation or identity, and religion has nothing to do here? Possibly terrorism is much more rooted in psychological and socia-political factors? Only these numbers tell us much: one billion of unemployed around the world. Let ask ourselves what all these people are busy with.

Posted by Louisa on December 07, 2008 at 02:20 PM GMT #

miliband looks handsome

Posted by j. on December 07, 2008 at 03:43 PM GMT #

When is the stereo type image of 'muslim' going to be replaced? Beards, hijabs, piety and duty, although more common place today in the UK, should not be the only accepted and most commonly used representation of 'muslim', frankly it's a bore - this stark and narrow version of Islam is being cemented in without question. This is not my understanding of my faith, it is sad that the government/ general public have begun to see through this lens alone. Where are the others, who are creative, broad minded, free spirited, awake to learning and experiences, wild and woolly, without prejudice, and still Muslim. Falling of the edge of this flat earth?

Posted by Lubna on December 10, 2008 at 10:42 PM GMT #

The Somali saga; lawlessness, pirates and insecurity; what is our government’s plan to get lasting peace in Somalia? In my opinion our government is shying away. I appreciate that now because of the piracy our government seems taking some leadership. However, stopping only piracy is not lasting solution. Somalia needs political stability. Can the Honourable Secretary of State shed light on Somalia Saga?

Posted by Hashim Duale on December 11, 2008 at 10:37 AM GMT #

I would like to congratulate David Miliband for showing the courage to stand up in front of the Pakistani youth and showing the guts to claim what he believes in. Thats what we require. This is the time to look into these question of identity, religion, nationality, nation-state, multi-cultural and multi-nationalism, west vs east, or north vs south, hegemony, etc etc. Its only de-mystifying our youth that we can bring the hope back and change the mind-set which unfortunately has started ruling the rostrum. So my suggestion to Miliband will be to do this more often and involve other Europeans and even Americans, if you can, in this nobel cause. Besides doing the surgery, the first aid, we all have a responsibility to leave this world in safer and saner hands. so keep it up Miliband.

Posted by Saeed Minhas on December 11, 2008 at 03:49 PM GMT #

As "being a Muslim" and "to associate terrorist with Islam" has been a favorite topic for the world. For the British Muslims and a common Muslims it's been harsh that all what our point of view is has been ignored and what the activists working against the harmony between major religion say, has been accepted. I would like to request you to please pick up what the major part of Muslims want. Nobody wishes to be called as a terrorist. Not only in Britain but all over the world Muslims are taken as “Muslims” not as a person living on the earth and wishing and working to maintain the worlds balance. This attitude should please not be encouraged and the responsibility is held with the leaders like you to guide the people though the right. Moreover, the need for inter-religion dialogue is increasing hour by hour and the efforts of holding this dialogue in-time should be promoted.

Posted by Akhlaq Ahmed on December 23, 2008 at 10:34 AM GMT #

The innocent civilian people which are being killed in the name of war on terror are terrorist or merely a victim of terrorism.and they are mostly Muslims including the people of Iraq,kashmir,Afghanistan and palestine. Discussions on such forums are good but practical steps should be taken to put these theories of humanism into practice.

Posted by zara on December 26, 2008 at 06:48 AM GMT #

This is no time for a Novice in Foreign Policy and David Miliband certainly shows he has the experience and ability for THE JOB

Posted by margaret maccormack on December 30, 2008 at 05:31 PM GMT #

As commented that UK is the most tolerated country for social sector.Atleast some ease should be shown by them in their foreign policy if they claim to be the most tolerating nation.Mr Blair without going into any negotiation with Afghan govt became an ally of the most selfish nationUSA.It seems you are being trapped by your own laws.As you have to go through it what you have cultivated for your country.But when it comes to international relation we don't see that tolerance which you claim.Muslim states are not asking any aid or assistance from the western powers who are transforming global policies.They only ask "live and let to live".

Posted by S.M.Jamal on January 05, 2009 at 06:52 PM GMT #

Post a Comment:
  • HTML Syntax: NOT allowed